KENDALL BEAR

Cracked Mirrors:
Writing the Entertainment Industry into Black Swan

The death, then, of a beautiful woman is, unquestionably,
the most poetical topic in the world.

– Edgar Allan Poe
"The Philosophy of Composition"

In the screenplay for Black Swan (Aronofsky, 2010), written by Mark Heyman, Andres Heinz, and John J. McLaughlin, the film's fictional ballet company functions as a microcosm of the broader film and entertainment industry — an institution that manufactures female perfection while simultaneously consuming and discarding the women who attempt to embody it. The main character, Nina Sayers (Natalie Portman), personifies this tragedy in show business. Her death is not accidental, nor incidental; it is the logical conclusion of an industry that romanticizes female suffering as beautiful art. That perfection is not simply technical mastery but a willingness to submit one's body and psyche to the male gaze, to fetishization, and ultimately to self-erasure.

Even before the events that take place in Black Swan, Nina's backstory is clear: she has been trained into this culture since birth. Through her authority-guided technical studies of ballet, she was led to believe that pain was necessary for excellence. Ballet, like film acting, demands total bodily discipline through thinness, control, endurance, and emotional availability on cue. Nina's bleeding feet, cracked toenails, and relentless rehearsals reflect a larger entertainment expectation, that the female body must be molded, restrained, and perfectly mutilated for public consumption. Her bulimic eating habits, obsessive self-surveillance, as well as several vomiting scenes reveal the traumatic stress under which she must perform. On page 77 of the screenplay, for example, Nina spots the ballet director Thomas Leroy (Vincent Cassel) and Lily (Mila Kunis) "conversing near [a] doorway. Lily nods and touches his arm. He smiles warmly, then notices Nina watching. His serious demeanor returns and he pulls away. He says goodbye to Lily. Lily follows his gaze and smirks at Nina, rubbing it in, before exiting herself." Setting up this scene earlier in the script, on page 12, Leroy brushes Nina aside to give attention to the newly arrived Lily. As a result, Nina purges imperfection in pursuit of flawlessness, moving symbolically closer to death as she moves closer to artistic "success." The body horror in the script that follows manifests in her skin tearing, feathers erupting, nails cracking, and bones snapping, which externalizes the psychological violence of those expectations. The transformation into the Black Swan is not mystical; it is the psychological manifestation of internalized pressure.

This pressure is magnified by those around her, and it can be argued that every major character embodies the characteristics of the Black Swan. They are all defined by passion, sexuality, and danger, except for Nina. From the beginning, she is characterized by her innocence and naivete which stands as a barrier between her and success. In most, if not all, renditions of Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky's Swan Lake, the ballerina who plays the White Swan must also play the Black Swan. Nina does not embody the darker and seductive version of her solo until after she has experienced horrific trauma and a degradation of her psyche. Like her dual part in the ballet, she is torn between what others expect her to be and who she actually is.

Her struggle begins to show outwardly in her mind's eye, manifesting in hallucinations. As explained by Ruth Doughty and Christine Etherington-Wright, Sigmund Freud's practice of psychoanalysis involves "treating mental disorders by investigating the interaction of conscious and unconscious elements in the patient's mind and bringing repressed fears and conflicts into the conscious mind, using techniques such as dream interpretation and free association." Though a treatment, psychoanalysis can also be used to study select characters in film if their internal conflicts are expressed outwardly. Through a psychoanalytic lens, Black Swan explores how performance spaces, influenced and controlled by the patriarchy, construct femininity as dualities: white and black, virgin and whore, purity and desire.

The film industry parallel becomes clearest through Thomas Leroy, the ballet's director, whose authority mirrors that of powerful male directors and producers in Hollywood. He tells Nina she is technically perfect but sexually repressed, which he claims prevents her portrayal of the Black Swan. She can embody innocence but not desire. His sexually explicit comments and invasive behavior, including groping her under the guise of artistic guidance, illustrate how women in entertainment are often pushed to access sexuality not for themselves, but to satisfy a male-defined standard of "authenticity," but one defined by Laura Mulvey's concept of the "male gaze." This view does not reflect the true nature of womanhood and can be damaging to the victim's concept of herself.

On page 35 of the screenplay, Leroy gives Nina "homework" to go home and pleasure herself, and she dutifully does so, not of her own volition but because she wants to feel perfect in her art and is willing to do anything to attain that perfection. Ballet is her world; she cannot separate her identity from her artistic craft. Leroy manipulates this fact by equating artistic growth with sexual awakening, reinforcing the idea that a woman must be both talented and erotically available to be considered complete. This dynamic exemplifies the male gaze mentality. On page 18, of the script, for example, Nina's body is evaluated not simply for technical ability. She's even brushed aside when Leroy says that he doesn't "care about [her] technique," and she "should know that by now." Her body is judged for its ability to provoke, seduce, and exude sexuality. On page 43, Leroy asks a male dancer if he would be "interested in f------ her," and the dancer snickers and shakes his head. Leroy continues by saying, "No, of course not. No one would be. Nina, your Black Swan still looks no different than your White Swan. She's just as...frigid." Unfortunately, she cannot repel this manipulation; she has been conditioned into obedience and childlike compliance by her mother and dance culture. Indeed, her need to please the director, audience, her mother, and herself becomes the engine for her psychological collapse.

The pressure to remain desirable is reinforced through Beth (Winona Ryder) and Erica (Barbara Hershey) who represent two possible futures within performance culture. Beth, Nina's predecessor, once celebrated for her talent, was discarded for aging. She is an illustration of female success in entertainment that is temporary and contingent on youth. Her body, once revered, is now obsolete. On page 5 of the script, she is mocked by the younger ballerinas in the company before she leaves: they say the company should hire "someone who's not approaching menopause" while comparing her to their "grandmother[s]." Forgetting they, too, will face the same fate.

Erica, Nina's mother, embodies the failed older performer archetype who "ran out of time," enviously projecting her own lost ambition onto her daughter while simultaneously freezing Nina in adolescence. In their shared apartment, Nina's bedroom is an eyesore of baby pink walls, frilly decorations, and stuffed animals, symbolizing her infantilization. She is trapped between hypersexualization in the professional sphere and enforced purity at home. The industry demands that she be the Black Swan by being sensual, free, and dangerous, while her upbringing confines her to the White Swan by being virginal, obedient, and perfect. This split repesents the core psychological tension of the film.

Nina's Freudian split can be read through the denial of Carl Jung's concept of individuation and how it "is nothing less than to divest the self of the false wrappings of the persona on the one hand and the suggestive power of primordial images on the other." Individuation is the lifelong process of integrating the unconscious with the conscious self in order to become a whole, authentic individual. This process requires confronting and assimilating the "shadow" self, which is in reference to Sigmund Freud's theories on "the unconscious, i.e. the repressed." The shadow represents the repressed, instinctual, and socially unacceptable aspects of the psyche. Nina, however, does not integrate her shadow; she is consumed by it. Rather than gradually integrating her Black and White Swan elements into a stable personality, Nina experiences them as an external, threatening double. The numerous mirrors in the screenplay that fracture her reflection symbolize this failure of integration. Instead of achieving individuation, she collapses under the pressure of becoming whole all at once.

Robert A. Johnson expands on Freud and Jung's idea of the shadow by describing the dual-self dynamic between the identity we consciously present, and the hidden aspects we deny or repress. In his eyes, there are "two 'shadows' (1) the dark side of the ego, which is carefully hidden from itself and which the ego will not acknowledge unless forced to by life's difficulties, and (2) that which has been repressed...lest it interfere with our egocentricity and, however devilish it may seem, is basically connected to the Self." Nina's ego is hyper-developed around perfection, so it is fragile because it depends entirely on external validation. The more she suppresses her darker impulses, the stronger they emerge in distorted forms like hallucinations, paranoia, and self-harm, such as scratching her skin until it bleeds.

Similarly, looking through a Freudian lens, her White Swan persona aligns with the ego's attempt to mediate social expectations, while the Black Swan reflects the erupting id of raw instinct, desire, and sexuality. Because Nina has never been allowed to express desire or aggression safely, her id surfaces passionately and violently rather than organically. Her transformation is not a healthy growth but an implosion: the ego shatters, the shadow overwhelms, and what appears to be artistic transcendence at her final performance is a failed and, ultimately, fatal attempt at integration.

As noted before, mirrors dominate the visual landscape. They're mentioned thirty-six times in the script, constantly fracturing Nina's reflection and suggesting a divided ego. They represent not just her psychological breakdown, but the process of self-surveillance required in entertainment culture. Nina is always watching herself, adjusting, correcting, and performing. She's controlled, delicate, technically immaculate, and conceals the rage, sexuality, hunger (for her craft and bulimic tendencies), and trauma from her life at home and in her professional life. As much as Nina resists the idea, the script suggests that these opposites are not separate identities but two halves of the same constructed femininity. These halves are akin to the virgin/whore dichotomy or the Madonna-Whore Dichotomy (MWD), which, as Bareket et al. phrase it, "denotes polarized perceptions of women in general as either 'good,' chaste, and pure Madonnas or as 'bad,' promiscuous, and seductive whores." MWD is not natural; it is imposed on Nina by Leroy, so she can serve as a sexual being for his pleasure and the audience's, but it's also imposed on her by Erica, a woman deeply entrenched by the expectations of patriarchy. In the screenplay, page 22, the writers describe the scene after Nina is chosen to be the White/Black Swan by Leroy. When she walks out of the bathroom stall, the word "WHORE" is written on the mirror in red lipstick. Some readers assume, due to other hallucinatory moments in the script, that Nina imagines the letters, externalizing what she internally or subconsciously thinks of herself.

Ultimately, Black Swan presents the entertainment industry as a system that aestheticizes female suffering. During Nina's death at her final performance, her last whispered words on page 102 of the script resonate for many women: "It was perfect." This line captures the haunting truth of performance culture, that a woman's ultimate triumph is often inseparable from her self-destruction. In achieving the Black Swan's passion, sexuality, and danger, Nina finally collapses under the weight of the very patriarchal duality that she has allowed to define her. Though the script was written by three men, they perfectly transcribed the struggle of many women performers into their work. Unveiling the ways in which show business has destroyed some of them, Heyman, Heinz, and McLaughlin wrote a spectacular study of feminine identity under relentless scrutiny, thus exposing how industries built on spectacle often require women to fracture, starve, sexualize, and ultimately sacrifice themselves in order to be seen as transcendent.

Back to Top
Review Home